Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Raw Materials, Part II

So, here's the thing: my eyes continue to be opened here by how we consume things in North America and Europe with absolutely NO REGARD for the source or origin of those items. I wrote about this before, and I will repeat it again: if we really thought about what it took for our gold, our food, our coffee and our gas to get to our fingers, mouths and cars (respectively), we might reconsider our choices.

I make this statement from the perspective of Colombia, specifically the Department of Quindío, in the heart of this country's coffee-growing region. You know: "Made from the best stuff on earth"? Yeah, that. Well, guess what else comes from Colombia? Cocaine. And I was infuriated by an article I read in this past Sunday's New York Times, which practically glorified the use of cocaine, talking about how it was totally the cool new drug. The article was in the Styles section, even.

Now, I will acknowledge the fact that some people are addicts and have practically no control over their drug use. Addiction is a disease, etc., and that's a different thing. But most of the people quoted in that article seem to be occasional users. And they don't even seem like terrible people. So, I think that they might reconsider using cocaine a bit if they knew about the chain of violence, corruption, pain and death that it takes for that cocaine to get from Colombian fields to their prissy hipster Williamsburg noses. With every line, they are treating Latin America like their own personal backyard cocaine crop.

Why do you think there is so much cocaine in Colombia? It's not because the Colombians are bad people or whatever; it's because there is a huge demand for it, in our country. A demand that is growing fast, if you believe the Times. And the path it takes to the US is ridden with absolute terror.

Latin America has been referred to a number of times as the "back yard" of the United States, often in a very paternalistic manner. But I was thinking the other day that the term "backy ard" has another meaning, too. You know how in everyone's back yard there is always one area that's a little unsightly, a part where the tools and the clutter all pile up? Things that you need, but you don't know where to put? Or maybe the ugly piping for your pool or your air conditioner that you can't hide anywhere else?

Well, Latin America is a little like that for the US, unfortunately. Latin America is the place where we pile up our necessities, our clutter, our piping, the parts we can't put in any other place. That sucks as it is. And really, we are perpetuating that when we use products that are produced in an unjust fashion. Like cocaine. Sweatshop clothes would be the logical extension of this argument, but I'm not going to get into that onr. Gold is another one: many gold mines are manned by workers who are fully exploited. And, of course, coffee.

Don't get me wrong: gold items, coffee products and clothes are obviously not all bad, and many are made, refined and manufactured in a just way. And as for cocaine, who am I to condemn the vices of others? But I will say that we should think carefully and get informed about the origins of the products we consume, because we might think twice about our choices that way.

It's very easy to gloss over this when you're at Target (or wherever) and something is gleaming before you, begging to be bought. But remember that what you're buying didn't come from the Target factory: its origins likely lay in the raw materials that are extracted from Latin America and other poorer regions in the southern hemisphere, at a very low cost by a multinational company, which then sells it to you at a huge mark-up. So tell that to the devil on your shoulder telling you to buy more crap that you don't really need.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

you are right carl... but unfortunately it's a double edged sword.

most of the population of the U.S. does not have the financial means to buy all of their necessities from 100%, completely honest, all american companies with american raw materials. stores like walmart and target (the former is satan whereas target does do more in terms of philanthropy but probably isn't completely good) are difficult to stop.

i can't wait to drive across this country with you this summer, carl. i understand how you feel about other countries' adversities... and it's not right that people have to suffer for the united states... but you will be surprised at how many of our fellow citizens live in similar conditions to what you are witnessing.

MANY people here cannot afford gold or cars and can hardly afford food... and they go to walmart or target for low prices (do you think they should care that the materials for their purchases were dishonestly extracted from south america?)

people work multiple jobs to support their families... they buy cheap shoes and notebooks at discount stores for their children to have for school and i don't blame them for not caring where the materials came from.

we have been raised very comfortably, carl. i'm not saying what is going on in south america is right, but i am saying that most of our country cannot afford to say no.

on the cocaine issue... i'm not even touching that one. lol

TIBOR said...

Carl
no sabes la emocionante aventura que nos estas compartiendo,..
suerte, buenos deseos y cuidate mucho.
Te quiere
TIBOR

Betsy Longstocking said...

Jessica, I think one of the main differences between the US and "those people who have to suffer for the United States" are the huge number of social programs and non-profit organizations at our fingertips. If we're creative enough, we have the resources to seek help or to help ourselves.

Imagine a government that doesn't have programs to help you pay for college or even a welfare program to help you pay for groceries or go to the dentist. Forget about gas money for a beat up car. Those people don't even have enough money to ride the city bus - if there is one. Where is South America's Wal-Mart, Jessica?

Sorry, but I'm sick of North Americans' long-suffering explanations of how "we're poor too". I've never seen a US child with an untreated case of tapeworm. Have you?

In terms of the global market, you're right. It's impossible to find anything anywhere that was made in the USA. That's consumerism for you. I think a first step would be remembering that a $5 candleholder and a $10 lawn chair from Target do not constitute a bare necessity.